The Toll focuses on the impact a violent crime has on a family and community.

“It’s tragic, really… We all have a story – a dark secret wrapped in emptiness and regret.
You know… The Toll.”
I’ve spent years immersed in the dark, tangled world of cold cases across the Ozarks.
This experience has reshaped how I view storytelling, justice, and the very fabric of our society. As an investigative journalist, my podcast projects have been more than just true-crime stories; they’ve been a relentless pursuit of truth, a voice for the voiceless, and a testament to the resilience of grieving families still seeking answers. Each case is a thread in a larger tapestry of systemic failures, overlooked evidence, and the haunting reality that justice delayed is often justice denied. These stories on The Toll matter because they remind us that behind every headline is a real person whose life was stolen – and a name that should never be forgotten.
– Nancy Simpson
The Toll Team

Nancy Simpson
CO-CREATOR, RESEARCHER, AUTHOR, AND HOST
Nancy Simpson describes herself as a storyteller. She is the creator, author and host of The Toll. Nancy is an accomplished journalist who has earned many prestigious awards for investigative news, breaking news, and severe weather coverage including twelve Edward R. Murrow awards. She has been recognized six times for “Best Radio Newscast” by the Missouri Broadcasters Association.
Pamela Shelby
Executive producer
Pamela is lead strategist and executive producer for The Toll Podcast. From shaping the series creative vision to managing its production, her contributions are integral to the series. Pamela’s recognition as the 2024 Clio Honoree for Innovation is a testament to her exceptional skill, creativity, and leadership in the world of creative production.